A state legislator in Indiana wants the state to pass a law requiring homework assignments for elementary school students and for parents to sign saying they supervised its completion. Teachers would then be required to make reports on the rate of completion, which would then be made public.

Where do begin critiquing this idea?

First, research has shown “zero” correlation between elementary school homework and academic success (see The Best Resources For Learning About Homework Issues) — even though the legislator wants to mandate “meaningful” homework assignments.

Secondly, I’m sure teachers in Indiana will be thrilled to have to submit yet another report.

Instead of spending the money to supervise and administer this effort, how about using it to offer stipends to teachers to make home visits to parents and create genuinely meaningful relationships?